Forum:Featured Article Nominations

Forums: Index > Downtown Danville > Featured Article Nominations

Here, any user may nominate an article for the status of Featured Article. A Featured Article (or "FA") is a page on the wiki that demonstrates the best of quality and is considered one of the greatest pages the wiki has/will have.

The criteria for an article is as followed:

1. The article must have excellent prose, devoid of typos and bad grammar.
2. It must be at least 3 paragraphs.
3. It must have some sort of plot to it and not just say something like "Phineas and Ferb builds a device that eats homework and Doof makes an inator to destroy pelicans."

To nominate an article, simply add the article name in Heading 2 (two equal signs) here. While voting for an article, please give suggestions of improvements so the article can truly be perfect and of FA status. If you find an article perfect, then you do not have to, but we strongly suggest you give opinions on its improvements so it can truly be perfect. Also, we will not accept unsigned comments, they will be omited and not counted.

Please do not opppose/support an article just because you don't like it or you feel like opposing/supporting it. They, too, will be not counted, and deleted.

Each support/oppose needs to have a good, sensible reason to why you chose the article to vote. We do not accept supports/opposes like "Great story!" or "This is lame." Those kind of votes will be invalid and you cannot revote for the same article again, even if your vote is invalid.

To see the articles that were previously nominated and the full details on the voting for each month, refer to the /Archive/ page.

For May 2012

Phineas and Ferb go to school

• Written By: Travis Platypus

• Nominated By: Perryfan825

Oppose

1. I can't even read all the way thorugh this. The grammar is bad and full of run-on sentences. The "paragraphs" are about two sentences long, with little detail. And the writing style isn't that great either. Sorry, but this is not worthy to be FA. -Spatula....I mean Maddyfae... I should've known with the context and all... 19:18, April 10, 2012 (UTC)

Comment

• This wiki makes no sense to me. I don't see any bad grammar in it and plus Apirl's featured article was a terrible article had had terrible spelling, terrible grammar, made no sense at all, and broke lots of rules yet it was still featured. It was not worthy to be featured article and this article was MUCH beter than that one so it just does not make sense to me. I wish you a very Perry Easter! (talk) 19:39, April 10, 2012 (UTC)

• Last month's FA was joke. ALL spelling and grammatical errors were purposeful. It was a satire to all bad fics out there. And yes, there is poor grammar in this article. I'm sorry you are unable to see it. -Spatula....I mean Maddyfae... I should've known with the context and all... 19:31, April 10, 2012 (UTC) PS: Please use a signature. Just end your comment with four tildes (~~~~)
• Still, it did not deserve to be featured article! The page should be deleted and it should NOT be a featured atricle no matter what! This article is fine and actually makes sense unlike the last featured atricle which broke MANY rules. I wish you a very Perry Easter! (talk) 19:39, April 10, 2012 (UTC)

Thirteen Roses

• Written By: Fossy
• Nominated By: Maddyfae

Support

1. This story may be short, but so sweet. Seeing a brother-sister moment with Candace and Ferb (instead of Phineas) is wonderful. For such a short story, quite a bit emotion is seen throughout it. Plus, the grammar and spelling is wonderful. -Spatula....I mean Maddyfae... I should've known with the context and all... 23:35, April 10, 2012 (UTC)